Every year around this time, I embark on a reread of Will Guidara’s book, Unreasonable Hospitality: The Remarkable Power of Giving People More Than They Expect.
This book should be required reading for anyone in hospitality, especially for managers. Will goes into not only customer service but also company culture. He also includes useful tidbits that could translate to your e-comms: social media, email, and booking sites.
I am typically an audiobook reader, but this book is so good and so full of great nuggets of wisdom that I bought a physical copy so I could highlight and annotate in the margins on my annual rereads.
Anywho, this book has been on my mind lately because of an affogato.
Last month, Bob and I did a date night at Bar Le Côte (our first since bringing The Intern, our almost 9-month-old baby, into the world). Our server brought over a sherry affogato while we were paying our bill. Something similar happened the last time I ate at Bell’s Los Alamos (another Companion Hospitality spot), when a server brought a cookie to our table while I was paying the check. In both cases, the transaction was over. They had no reason to bring us dessert, but they did it anyway.
Just because I’ve read Unreasonable Hospitality doesn’t make these moments of surprise and delight any less… surprising and delightful. And that’s the point of this post.
Wineries Are Hospitality Businesses
It can be easy to forget this if you sell most of your wine online, or if your tasting room is just one piece of a bigger operation, but a winery is a hospitality business first and foremost. Wine is meant to be shared over delicious food and conversation.
Guidara’s whole idea is that the moments people remember aren’t the ones that meet expectations. They’re the ones that exceed them in a way nobody asked for or could have predicted. What’s great is that these moments of Unreasonable Hospitality don’t need to be (and often shouldn’t be) expensive or time-consuming. Here are a few I’ve experienced and heard about:
The flowers for a first-time grandma. A couple of years ago at DTC Symposium, the folks at Booker Winery learned that a club member was looking forward to welcoming her first grandbaby. The team sent her flowers, and then sent her daughter a bottle of rosé with a note along the lines of “hey, it’s been a long nine months.” They created a member for life with a simple but impactful gesture.
Birthday wishes on the tasting sheet. Brave & Maiden Estate adds the guests’ names, and the reason they’re visiting (if there is one), to the top of the tasting sheet. “Happy birthday, [name]!” It takes no time at all, and it changes the whole experience for guests by showing them they care that they are there.
Congrats on Q3! Bell’s does something similar with their menus. When you book, they ask why you’re visiting, and they print a custom menu. One time Bob and I went to Bell’s because my accountant told me I needed to spend more money (lol, don’t threaten me with a good time) and suggested I take my husband to dinner to celebrate something. When they asked why we were visiting, I wrote “Successful Q3!” because it had been the best quarter my business had ever had. Bells wrote “Congrats on an awesome Q3!” at the top of our menus. That was three years ago, and I still think about it.
Customer of the day. I can’t remember who I heard about this from but I have an inkling I learned about it during another past DTCWS. One winery posts a “customer of the day” on social media is a small way to bring hospitality online.
Wall of fame. FOXEN offers some guests an extra taste of wine at the end of their tasting, but they do it blind. Whoever guesses correctly gets their photo taken and added to the Wall of Fame. Customers are stoked because they get an extra taste of wine and a chance to show off a little. I’ve seen guests bring friends in to show them they got onto the Wall of Fame, and folks who got the wine wrong come back to try again. It’s such a simple way to get repeat visitors.
Why These Work
These work because they’re specific. Guests got something that proved the host was paying attention. They’re also not attached to a pitch. The desserts came after the checks, and the flowers weren’t an upsell. People tend to like it when hospitality isn’t transactional. All of these things are relatively cheap and memorable, too. And the Wall of Fame shows these moments of Unreasonable Hospitality don’t have to be one-offs! You can build them into the experience so they happen for every guest, no matter who is working that day.
Unreasonable Hospitality… but online
For wineries that do a lot of business outside of the thasting room, the same principles can still apply! And the bar for standing out is surprisingly low.
Reply to DMs and comments with the person’s name. It takes five seconds to go to their profile and see what their first name is (if they’ve listed it).
Include a handwritten note in a shipment, especially for first orders or club anniversaries.
Remember a detail from a previous order or message and mention it later. For example, I had someone DM one of my clients asking if we had space available that weekend because it was their birthday and were making a trip up our way. I made a note to follow up with them the day of their birthday and sent them a “Happy Birthday! Hope you have an amazing time!” They sent me pictures from their visit and told me they had a great time. They’ve been back multiple times since.
How to Train Your Team to Be Unreasonably Hospitable
Collect As Much Info As Possible. Ask people why they are visiting or what they are ordering wine for. This can give you valuable info you can use later to surprise and delight.
Give permission and a set budget for funsies. Your team should be able to surprise guests without asking a manager every time. If you can set a small weekly budget earmarked for “shenanigans” or “above and beyond,” your team can get creative.
Do a quick pre-shift to review your reservations and see if there are opportunities to surprise and delight the guests on the books.
Likewise, do a post-shift rundown with your team and ask them how they gave unreasonable hospitality. Your team can learn from each other and find ways to give amazing service every day.
Have them read Unreasonable Hospitality. I said it above, but I believe this book should be required reading for everyone who works in Hospitality, ESPECIALLY your managers. You could even do a book club with your team where each week you read a few chapters and then discuss what you learned and what you’re inspired to do at the end of the month.
Note: A free dessert doesn’t make up for shitty service. Unreasonable hospitality needs to build on the basics. If you don’t have basic customer service standards in place, no amount of surprising and delighting is going to save you.
ACTION ITEM! Look at tomorrow’s tasting reservations or your next batch of club orders and think about one small, specific thing you can do for one person that they won’t expect. Is someone’s birthday coming up? Can you send them a handwritten note via snail mail? Did someone recently ask you if you are dog-friendly? Could you have a chew toy or something ready to give them when they visit? Get weird! Get creative!
What are some moments of hospitality you’ve experienced? Reply to this email or leave a comment; I’d really love to hear about it!
Liked this post? Here are more you might find interesting:
This post focused on one of my favorite books. Here are a few other business and self-development books I’ve loved:
Disclosure: Some of the links in this post are affiliate links. I may make a small commission from purchases made through some of those links, at no extra cost to you. I promise to only ever link products I know and believe in! Do know that any purchase you make via one of these affiliate links is greatly appreciated, as it will allow me to continue to provide free content to you!







